Monday, March 17, 2008

Mexico Not Bowing To Pressure.

I feel for Brenda Martin and what is happening to her, BUT, she made the choice to challenge the Mexican courts, and is losing. Basically, I think she made the mistake of thinking that Mexico was as liberal as Canada, and that she had the same human rights there as she would have here.

Bernier to discuss jailed Canadian with Mexico

National media attention has thrown Martin's case into the spotlight and the Canadian government reacted to public scrutiny last week by issuing a diplomatic note of protest to Mexico. The note was issued days after Martin learned her constitutional challenge -- which stated her human rights had been violated -- was rejected by the Mexican courts.

According to the judge's ruling, Martin's human rights -- including access to a translator while being interviewed by police and during court appearances -- had not been violated. The judge also stated Martin had confessed to her crimes.
(From what I understand she has been in Mexico for ten years, does she not know the language yet?)

So, not only is she involved in a criminal trial, she has also initiated a constitutional challenge. It was the constitutional challenge that was denied. Right or wrong, the judge ruled on the matter, and if she persists, she will spend more time behind bars.

Martin's lawyer, Guillermo Cruz Rico, said Sunday her case is something new for him as he has never seen a constitutional challenge handled in such a way.

After reviewing the judge's ruling, he said only evidence from one side was considered in the decision.

"After we reviewed the ruling we decided to appeal the decision," Cruz said, adding Martin had given him permission to do so despite proclaiming last week she would not.


Maybe some lawyer out there can help me understand how appealing the decision is going to get her released from prison sooner. Either she is getting bad advise, or she is naive, or both.

Finally, why is one hysterical women important enough for the Prime Minister to intervene with the President of Mexico?

However, Martin's friend and advocate, Deb Tieleman, said she believes the only way the former resident of Trenton, Ont., is going to be released is if Prime Minister Stephen Harper intervenes.

This might be harse, but you go to another country, you better abide by their laws, and just because you have a Canadian passport, do not expect to get rescued, expect help, but don't expect our laws and human rights to apply in other countries.

11 comments:

Platty said...

It says she has confessed to her crimes. So, does this mean that she is asking to be released on a technicality?

I am not clear on why the Canadian government should be expected to step in here.

Unless, of course, they have information or evidence that the woman is indeed innocent of the crimes she has been accused.

While I would not want to be in her position, the fact of the matter is, if you do not want to be in prison, don't break the law.



==

Anonymous said...

I am extremely frustrated at all the "calls" for SH to call the president of Mexico - What are these people expecting is going to happen.

Plus - there are two sides of every story - we are only hearing Brenda Martin's side.

I feel for her, but asking the President of Mexico to release her is as idiotic as the President of Mexico calling our Prime Minister and demanding we release a mexican prisoner.

Plus, I hear her all the time on the phone and we see interviews with here. If her rights are so violated, why is she able to make all these pleas.

Anonymous said...

Ezra Levant's human rights are being abused in Canada and not a peep from anyone...well maybe a few...but certainly not the media. Whats with you people in Canada??? Why aren't you demanding PMSH and the Mexican Ambassador intervene. Why isn't W5 on this? Where are the CBC "journalists" when you need them? Where is Jack and Stephane?

Al in Mexico

Anonymous said...

You people are nazis. Honest to God nazis.

KURSK said...

Yeah...that's right anonymous..and we'll be at your door around midnight.Have your bag packed.[sarc]

wilson said...

Ms. Martin worked for the dude for 10 months and got roughly a $24,000in severance.
Ms. Martin invested $10,000 of that severance money in one of Waage's companies.
Ms. Martin was working illegally in Mexico when she was arrested.

hunter said...

I didn't know she was working illegally in Mexico, thanks Wilson!

Get her to trial under Mexico's laws, it's their country she was in.

We can not step in for every Canadian who is jailed anywhere in the world. The bleading heart lefties even want Afghan prisoners held under Canadian law. Enough is enough.

Anonymous said...

I didn't know she was working illegally in Mexico, thanks Wilson!

That's part of your problem...and the "dark" you need to climb faster out of. You believe everything everyone tells you, as long as it supports your opinion.

Where's the source on that, Wilson?

Anonymous said...

you pissants, not worth the time

hunter said...

Anon 8:45, what exactly is your point? Oh, your point is to slag people, showing your lack of intellect, I get it now!

Anonymous said...

lack of intellect. hahaha, rich.